The Nature of Miracles
Keywords:
miracles, skepticism, theism, D. Hume, J. L. Mackie, R. SwinburneAbstract
According to the traditional Christian picture God also works miracles – He sometimes causes events that do not happen in accordance with the physical laws which otherwise firmly hold. This theistic teaching has been attacked with several arguments, and in this article I will defend the theistic teaching against two arguments against miracles – one by Hume, and another by Mackie. Hume claims that a miracle, being a violation of the laws of nature, is always more unbelievable than a natural explanation of the certain testimony of a miracle. In answer to this position I expound on Swinburne’s answer, that in certain cases, where we have good reasons to believe certain testimonies (because of the reliability of witnesses, our spiritual and moral experience and similar), the evidence for a miracle can be stronger than the evidence against that miracle, although our whole sensory experience may be of a non-miraculous nature. To Mackie’s proposal of postulating certain unknown physical laws which would explain a miracle in a natural way, I answer that sometimes the circumstances which are described in a reliable miracle story suggest more a supernatural explanation of the phenomenon than a natural one.
Downloads
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2000 Društvo za analitično filozofijo in filozofijo znanosti

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.