The Right to a Fair Trial of Legal Persons Throughout the Case Law of the ECHR and the CJEU
Abstract
The ambition of this article is an analysis of the right to a fair trial of legal entities through the prism of the jurisprudence of the ECtHR and the CJEU. Despite the factual admission of the right to a fair trial to companies in the case law of the Courts, the absence of a strong theoretical foundation and persuasive explanation in their judgments raises ambiguity as to the ECtHR and the CJEU positions in that regard. In that context, the article examines landmark cases of both Courts and relevant doctrinal considerations concerning the application of guarantees provided by the right to a fair trial to legal persons. The ECtHR case law is considered inconsistent and the Strasbourg court, it appears, tries to avoid any far-reaching conclusions. The CJEU in its case law, due to the inherent focus of EU law on economic values, interprets the right to a fair trial of companies broadly, and sometimes, broader than it is needed. It is concluded that the issue requires more attention from both the Courts and legal scholars, in the view of serious consequences the ignorance and unfounded admission of any fundamental right could entail to the society and economy.
Downloads
References
Emberland, M. (2003) Compensating Companies for Non-Pecuniary Damage: Comingersoll S.A. v. Portugal and the Ambivalent Expansion of the ECHR Scope. British Yearbook of International Law, 74(1).
Emberland, M. (2006) The Human Rights of Companies, Exploring the Structure of ECHR Protection. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Engström, J. (2011) The Principle of Effective Judicial Protection after the Lisbon Treaty. Reflection in The Light of Case C-279/09 DEB Deutsche Energiehandels- und Beratungsgesellschaft mbH. Review of European Administrative Law, 4(2).
European Court of Human Rights (2022) Guide on Article 6 of the ECHR, Right to a Fair Trial (Civil Limb).
Gutman, K. (2019) The Essence of the Fundamental Right to an Effective Remedy and to a Fair Trial in the Case-Law of the Court of Justice of the European Union: The Best Is Yet to Come? German Law Journal, 20.
Isiksel, T. (2016) The Rights of Man and the Rights of the Man-Made: Corporations and Human Rights. Human Rights Quarterly, 38(2).
Isiksel, T. (2019) Corporate Human Rights Claims under the ECHR. Georgetown Journal of Law & Public Policy, 17.
Johan Settem, O. (2016) Applications of the ‘Fair Hearing’ Norm in ECHR Article 6(1) to Civil Proceedings, With Special Emphasis on the Balance Between Procedural Safeguards and Efficiency. Switzerland: Springer International Publishing.
Julicher, M., Henriques, M., Amat Blai, A., and Policastro, P. (2019) Protection of the EU Charter for Private Legal Entities and Public Authorities? The Personal Scope of Fundamental Rights within Europe Compared. Utrecht Law Review, 15(1).
Kellerbauer, M., Klamert, M., and Tomkin, J. (2019) The EU Treaties and the Chapter of Fundamental Rights: A Commentary. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Kulick, A. (2021) Corporate Human Rights? The European Journal of International Law, 32(2).
Oliver, P. (2015) Companies and Their Fundamental Rights: A Comparative Perspective. The International and Comparative Law Quarterly, 64(3).
Oliver, P. (2022) What Fundamental Rights, if Any, Should Companies Enjoy? A Comparative Perspective. Revue Européenne du Droit, 4.
Peers, S., Hervey, T., Kenner, J., and Ward, A. (2021) The Charter of Fundamental Rights: A Commentary, 2nd edition. Hart Publishing.
Rozakis, C. (2006) The Right to a Fair Trial in Civil Cases: Article 6 Para. 1 of the ECHR. Id-Dritt, 19.
Sanchez-Graells, A., and Marcos, F. (2014) “Human Rights” Protection for Corporate Antitrust Defendants: Are We Not Going Overboard? University of Leicester, School of Law Research Paper, 14(03), http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2389715.
Schabas, W. (2015) The European Convention on Human Rights: A Commentary. Oxford University Press.
Schütze, R. and Tridimas, T. (2018) Oxford Principles of European Union Law, Volume 1: The European Union Legal Order. Oxford University Press.
Scolnicov, A (2013) Lifelike and Lifeless in Law: Do Corporations Have Human Rights? University of Cambridge Faculty of Law Research Paper, 13 http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2268537.
Teleki, C. (2021) Due Process and Fair Trial in EU Competition Law. Brill.
van den Muijsenbergh, W., and Rezai, S. (2012) Corporations and the European Convention on Human Rights. Global Business & Development Law Journal, 25(1).
Veenbrink, M. (2015) Privilege against Self-Incrimination in EU Competition Law: A Deafening Silence? Legal Issues of Econ Integration, 42.
Višekruna, A. (2018) Protection of Rights of Companies before the European Court of Human Rights. EU and Comparative Law Issues and Challenges Series (ECLIC), doi: https://doi.org/10.25234/eclic/6524.
Wilcox, V. (2018) A Company's Right to Damages for Non-Pecuniary Loss. Cambridge University Press.
