Climate Change-Related Displacement and the Determination of Refugee Status under the 1951 Refugee Convention
Abstract
Climate change and climate-driven migration are two of the defining challenges of the twenty-first century, and there is no legal framework for protecting those displaced across national borders for climate-related reasons. The 1951 Refugee Convention hardly applies to human mobility in the context of climate change. This paper was written in the hopes of initiating a discussion concerning an alternative perspective through which persons fleeing natural disasters linked to climate change may satisfy the eligibility conditions for recognition of refugee status. Expanding the definition of refugee as defined in the Convention by including the notion of vulnerability to climate disasters that are caused by the underlying socio-economic conditions in the claimant’s home country and the role of discrimination in causing differential exposure to the climate-related disasters in legal definitions might open the door for the availability of refugee status for persons fleeing in the context of climate change. This paper proposes the adoption of a reformed human rights-based interpretation, particularly with regard to the individual nature of refugee status determination. Recalibrating the Convention to facilitate climate-induced migration could reduce political tension and social unrest in receiving countries.
Povzetek
Podnebne spremembe in migracije, ki jih povzroča podnebje, so eden od glavnih izzivov enaindvajsetega stoletja, vendar ni pravnega okvira za zaščito oseb, ki so zaradi podnebnih sprememb razseljene prek državnih meja. Konvencija o statusu beguncev iz leta 1951 se skorajda ne uporablja za mobilnost ljudi v okviru podnebnih sprememb. Ta dokument je bil napisan v upanju, da bo sprožil razpravo o alternativni perspektivi, s katero bi osebe, ki bežijo pred naravnimi nesrečami, povezanimi s podnebnimi spremembami, lahko izpolnile pogoje za priznanje statusa begunca. Razširitev opredelitve begunca, kot je opredeljena v Konvenciji, z vključitvijo pojma ranljivosti za podnebne nesreče, ki so posledica temeljnih družbenoekonomskih razmer v prosilčevi matični državi, in vloge diskriminacije pri povzročanju različne izpostavljenosti s podnebnimi nesrečami povezanim nesrečam v pravne opredelitve bi lahko odprla vrata za pridobitev statusa begunca za osebe, ki bežijo zaradi podnebnih sprememb. Ta dokument predlaga sprejetje reformirane razlage, ki temelji na človekovih pravicah, zlasti glede individualne narave določanja statusa begunca. Preoblikovanje Konvencije za olajšanje migracij, ki jih povzročajo podnebne spremembe, bi lahko zmanjšalo politične napetosti in socialne nemire v državah sprejema.
Downloads
References
Sumudu, A., Schapper, A. (2019) Human Rights and the Environment: Key Issues. Oxford: Routledge.
Bodansky, D., Brunnee, J., and Rajamani, L. (2017) International Climate Change Law. Oxford: OUP.
Broberg, M. (2020) State of Climate Law: The Third Pillar of International Climate Change Law: Explaining “Loss and Damage” after the Paris Agreement. Climate Law, 10(2), p. 1-8.
Broberg, M., and Martinez Romera, B. (2021) The Third Pillar of International Climate Change Policy: On 'Loss and Damage' after the Paris Agreement. Oxford: Routledge.
Cher Weixia, C., Dundes Renteln, A. (2023) International Human Rights: A Survey. Cambridge: CUP.
Crawford, J. (2019) Brownlie's Principles of Public International Law. 9th edition. Oxford: OUP.
Evans, M. D, ed. (2018) International Law. 5th edition. Oxford: OUP.
Fletcher, L. E., Stover, E. and Weinstein, H.M. (2005) After the Tsunami: Human Rights of Vulnerable Populations. Human Rights Center of UC Berkeley and East-West Center.
Goodwin-Gill, G. S, McAdam, J., Dunlop, E. (2021) The Refugee in International Law. 4th edition. Oxford: OUP.
Hathaway, J., and Foster, M. (2014) The Law of Refugee Status. 2nd. Cambridge: CUP.
IPCC (2021) Contribution of Working Group I to the IPCC Sixth Assessment Report (AR6), Climate Change 2021: the Physical Science Basis. Cambridge: CUP.
Walter, K. and Schrepfer, N. (2012) Protecting People Crossing Borders in the Context of Climate Change Normative Gaps and Possible Approaches. UNHCR2012, n.d.
Klein, D., Maria Carazo, P., Doelle, M., Bulmer, J., and Higham, A. (2017) The Paris Agreement on Climate Change: Analysis and Commentary. Oxford: OUP.
Knox, H. J. (2020) The Paris Agreement as a Human Rights Treaty. In: Akande, D. et al. (ed.) Human Rights and 21st Century Challenges. Oxford: OUP, p. 323-347.
Knox, J. H, and Pejan, R. (2018) The Human Right to a Healthy Environment. Cambridge: CUP.
Kohl, K. (2022) Driving Justice, Equity, Diversity, and Inclusion. Oxford: CRC Press.
Lawson, S. (2021) Global Politics. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Marquardt, F. (2021) The New Nomads: How the migration revolution is making the world a better place. London: Simon & Schuster.
Mayer, B. (2022) International Law Obligations on Climate Change Mitigation. Oxford: OUP.
McAdam, J. (2012) Climate Change, Forced Migration and International Law. Oxford: OUP.
McGrath, M. (2022) Climate change: UN warns key warming threshold slipping from sight, BBC, accessed February 13 2023, available at: Climate change: UN warns key warming threshold slipping from sight - BBC News.
McGuire, B. (2022) Hothouse Earth: An Inhabitant's Guide. London: Icon Books.
Miller, T. (2017) Storming the Wall: Climate Change, Migration, and Homeland Security. San Francisco: City Lights.
Nagtzaam, G., Evan van Hook, Guilfoyle, D. (2020) International Environmental Law: A case Study Analysis. Oxford: Routledge.
OHCHR. (2022) Australia violated Torres Strait Islanders' rights to enjoy culture and family life, UN Committee finds, available at: https://www.ohchr.org/en/press-releases/2022/09/australia-violated-torres-strait-islanders-rights-enjoy-culture-and-family (accessed January 25, 2023).
Historic UN Human Rights case opens door to climate change asylum claims. January 21, 2020. https://www.ohchr.org/en/press-releases/2020/01/historic-un-human-rights-case-opens-door-climate-change-asylum-claims (accessed January 25, 2023).
Orlando, E. (2021) Principles, Standards and Voluntary Commitments in International Environmental Law. In E. Techera et al. (eds), Routledge Handbook of International Environmental Law, Oxford: Routledge, Ch. 2.
Cecily, R., Blokker, N. et al. (2022) An Introduction to Public International Law. Cambridge: CUP.
Sands, P., Peel, J., Fabra, A. and MacKenzie, R. (2018) Principles of Environmental Law. 4th edition. Cambridge: CUP.
Scott, M. (2020) Climate Change, Disasters, and the Refugee Convention. Cambridge: CUP.
Smith, R. K. M. (2020) International Human Rights Law. 9th edition. Oxford: OUP.
Techera, E., Lindley, J., N Scott, K., and Telesetsky, A. Routledge Hanbook of International Environmenta Law. 2nd edition. London: Routledge.
Thomas, A., Benjamin, L. (2021) Non-economic Loss and Damage: Lessons from Displacement in the Caribbean. In: Broberg, M. (ed.) The Third Pillar of International Climate Change Policy: On ‘Loss and Damage’ After the Paris Agreement, Oxford: Routledge, p. 34.
Thunberg, G., ed. (2022) The Climate Book. London: Penguin.
Toussaint, P. and Martinez Blanco, A. (2021) A human rights-based approach to loss and damage under the climate change regime. In: Broberg, M., Martinez Romera, B. (ed.) The Third Pillar of International Climate Change Policy: On ‘Loss and Damage’ After the Paris Agreement. Oxford: Routledge.
Twigg, J. (2004) Disaster Risk Reduction: Mitigation and Preparedness in Development and Emergency Programming. ODI Humanitarian Practice Network Good Practice Review No. 9, assessed 22 February 2023, available at: https://www.preventionweb.net/files/8450_gprch14.pdf.
Vince, G. (2022) Nomad Century: How to Survive the Climate Upheaval. London: Penguin.
Wewerinke-Singh, M. (2020) State Responsibility, Climate change and Human Rights under International Law. Oxford: Hart.
Williams, J. (2022) Why climate change is inherently racist, BBC, accessed January 26, 2023, available at: Why climate change is inherently racist - BBC Future.
Woerdman, E., Roggenkamp, M,. and Holwerda, M. (2022) Essential EU Climate Law. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
Wold, C., Hunter, D and Powers, M. (2009) Climate Change and the Law. LexisNexis.
Worland, J. (2022) The Selfish Case for Climate Justice. TIME.
