Citizenship by Investment Programs from the Perspective of International and EU Law
A growing number of States have been offering so-called citizenship by investment programs (CBI) or related residence by investment programs (RBI), where they offer residence and/or their nationality to foreigners willing to invest a considerable sum in their economies and/or to donate to their budget or other public funds. We focus on the CBI. Among States that offer specific CBI programs are mainly Caribbean states, but also three EU Member States, namely Bulgaria, Cyprus and Malta. The choice of an investment or donation as one of the grounds for the acquisition of the nationality of a (Member) State is in principle a legitimate choice under both international and EU law. In Section 2, we will first offer some thoughts on privileged naturalizations in State interest in general, and specifically about investment migration, before we embark on the discussion of the CBI schemes that are offered in Bulgaria, Cyprus and Malta. Section 3 explores the principle of national autonomy and its limitations both in international and EU law, with the focus on the existing CBI programs in the EU and their compatibility with international and EU law. Moreover, we will analyse the approach of the EU institutions towards such schemes.
Cambien, N. (2012). Union Citizenship and Immigration: Rethinking the Classics?, European Journal of Legal Studies, 5(1), pp. 10–37.
Carrera Nuñez, S. (2015). How much does EU Citizenship Cost? The Maltese Citizenship-forSale affair: A Breakthrough for Sincere Cooperation in Citizenship of the Union? In Carrera Nuñez, S., and De Groot D.-R. (eds), European Citizenship at the Crossroads: The Role of the European Union on Loss and Acquisition of nationality (Wolf Legal Publishers), pp. 293–326.
Chalmers, D., Davies, G., and Monti, G. (2016). Euroepan Union Law (CUP).
Coutts, S. (2019). Bold and Thoughtful: The Court of Justice intervenes in nationality law. Case C-221/17 Tjebbes. European Law Blog, available at https://europeanlawblog.eu/2019/03/25/bold-and-thoughtful-the-court-of-justice-intervenes-in-nationality-law-case-c-221-17-tjebbes/
Costello, C. (2011). Citizen of the Union: Above Abuse? In De la Feria, R., and Vogenauer, S. (eds), Prohibition of Abuse of Law: A New General Principle of EU Law? (Oxford: Hart Publishing).
Crawford, J. (2012). Brownlie's Principles of Public International Law (Oxford: OUP).
De Groot, D. A. J. G. (2018). Free Movement of Dual EU Citizens, European Papers, 3(3), pp. 1075–1113.
De Groot, G.-R. (1998). Een nieuwe poging tot wijziging van de Rijkswet op het Nederlanderschap. In: Jessurun d’Oliveira, H. U. (ed), Trends in het nationaliteitsrecht (SDU 1998), pp. 103–106.
De Groot, G.-R. (1999). Verder op weg naar een hernieuwd nationaliteitsrecht, Asiel- & Migrantenrecht, pp. 13–22.
De Groot, G.-R. (2005). Towards a European Nationality Law. In Schneider, H. (ed), Migration, Integration and Citizenship: A Challenge for Europe's Future. Volume I (Maastricht: Forum Maastricht).
De Groot, G.-R., and Vonk, O. W. (2015). International Standards on Nationality Law (Wolf Legal Publishers).
Džankić, J. (2019). The Global Market for Investor Citizenship (Cham: Springer International Publishing).
Jessurun d’Oliveira, H. U. (2016). Automatisch verlies nationaliteit voor Nederlander buitenaf onhoudbaar, Nederlands Juristenblad, pp. 248–255.
Jessurun d’Oliveira, H. U. (2018). Union citizenship and Beyond, EUI Working Paper Law 2018⁄15.
Kälin, C. H. (2019). Ius Doni in International Law and EU Law (Leiden/Boston: Brill/Nijhoff).
Kochenov, D. (2009). Ius Tractum of Many faces: European Citizenship and the Difficult Relationship Between Status and Rights, COLUM. J. EUR. L., 15(2), pp. 169–237.
Kochenov, D. (2013). The Right to Have What Rights?, ELJ, 19, pp. 502–516.
Kochenov, D. (2010). Rounding up the Circle: The Mutation of Member States’ Nationalities under Pressure from EU Citizenship, EUI Robert Schuman Centre for Advanced Studies Paper No 23/201.
Kochenov, D. (2017). The Citizenship of Personal Circumstances in Europe. In Thym, D. (ed), Questioning EU Citizenship: Judges and the Limits of Free Movement and Solidarity in the EU (Oxford: Hart Publishing).
Kochenov, D. (2018). Citizenship for Real: Its Hypocrisy, Its Randomness, Its Price. In Bauböck, R. (ed), Debating Transformations of National Citizenship (Cham: Springer Verlag), pp. 51–56.
Kochenov, D. (2019). The Tjebbes Fail, European Papers, Insight, 4(1), pp. 319–336.
Kudryashova, S. (2019). The Sale of Conditional EU Citizenship: The Cyprus Investment Programme under the Lens of EU Law, Investment Migration Research Paper IMCPB 2019/3 14.
Marrero González G. (2015). Civis Europaeus sum? Consequences with regard to Nationality Law and EU Citizenship Status of the Independence of a Devolved Part of an EU Member State (Oisterwijk: Wolf Legal Publishers).
Nic Shuibhne, N. (2010). The Resilience of EU Market Citizenship, Common Market Law Review, 47(6), pp. 1597–1628.
Nic Shuibhne, N. (2006). Derogating from the Free Movement of Persons: When Can EU Citizens Be Deported?’ Cam. YB Eur L, 8, pp. 187–227.
Sarmiento, D. (2019). EU Competence and the Attribution of Nationality in Member States, Investment Migration Working Papers IMC-RP2019/2.
Shaw, J. (2018). EU citizenship: still a fundamental status?, EUI Working Paper RSCAS 2018/14.
Spiro, P. J. (2019). Nottebohm and ‘Genuine Link’: Anatomy of a Jurisprudential Illusion, Investment Migration Working Papers IMC-RP2019/1.
Tratnik, M. (2018). Pravo državljanstva (Ljubljana: GV Založba).
Tratnik, M., and Weingerl, P. (2019). Investment Migration and State Autonomy: A Quest for the Relevant Link, Investment Migration Working Papers IMC-RP 4.
Thym, D. (2017). The Evolution of Citizens’ Rights in Light of the EU’s Constitutional Development. In Thym, D. (ed), Questioning EU Citizenship (Oxford: Bloomsbury/Hart).
Van der Brink, M. (2019). EU citizenship and (fundamental) rights: Empirical, normative, and conceptual problems, European Law Journal, 25, pp. 21–36.
Wollenschläger, F. (2011). A New Fundamental Freedom beyond Market Integration: Union Citizenship and its Dynamics for Shifting the Economic Paradigm of European Integration, European Law Journal, 17(1), pp. 1–34.
© University of Maribor, Faculty of Law, University Press
Free to Read