Ekonomski vidiki določanja odškodnin v primeru kršitev pravil konkurenčnega prava

  • Tanja Bratina Graduate in law, legal consultant at Law firm Avbreht, Zajc & Partners, Ltd.
Keywords: models for quantification of harm, harm caused by restrictive practices, quantification of harm, loss of profit

Abstract

Economic Aspects of the Determination of Damages in Antitrust Cases. Private enforcement of competition law infringements in Slovenia has not been sufficiently developed yet. This is definitely also attributable to the fact that the calculation of the amount of damage suffered because of the infringement of the competition law rules is highly complex and difficult. In order to facilitate the determination of the amount of damages caused by restrictive practices for the parties and the court, the European Commission prepared Draft Guidance Paper on quantifying harm in actions for damages based on breaches of the EU antitrust rules and held a public consultation on that document from 17 June to 30 September 2011. The purpose of this paper is to outline the proposal, both economic and legal aspects, which are contained in the Draft guidelines and to present legislative solutions and case law in that context.

 

Ekonomski vidiki določanja odškodnin v primeru kršitev pravil konkurenčnega prava. Zasebno uveljavljanje kršitev pravil konkurenčnega prava v Sloveniji še ni razvito v zadostni meri. K temu zagotovo prispeva tudi dejstvo, da je samo vprašanje višine škode, ki nastane zaradi kršitve pravil konkurence, izrazito kompleksno in zahtevno. Z namenom olajšanja določanja višine škode, ki je povzročena z omejevalnimi ravnanji, je Evropska komisija strankam in sodiščem junija 2011 dala v javno posvetovanje Osnutek smernic za ocenjevanje škode v odškodninskih tožbah zaradi kršitve člena 101 ali 102 Pogodbe o delovanju Evropske unije. Namen tega prispevka je orisati ekonomske in pravne predloge, ki jih vsebuje Osnutek smernic, ter predstaviti zakonske rešitve in prakso na tem področju.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Author Biography

Tanja Bratina, Graduate in law, legal consultant at Law firm Avbreht, Zajc & Partners, Ltd.

Ljubljana, Slovenia. E-mail: tanja.bratina@azodvetniki.com.

References

Ahtik, M., Vlahek, A. (2011) Določanje odškodnin v primeru kršitev antitrusta, Podjetje in delo, 37(6/7), str. 1344–1359.

Centre for European Policy Studies, Erasmus University Rotterdam in Luiss Guido Carli (2007) Making antitrust damages actions more effective in the EU: welfare impact and potential scenarios, poročilo za Direktorat za konkurenco, dostopno na: http://ec.europa.eu/competition/antitrust/actionsdamages/files_white_paper/impact_study.pdf#page=441.

Connor, L. (2006) The Size of Cartel Overcharges: Implications for U.S. and EU fining policies, izvleček dostopen na http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=988722.

Delegado, J., Perez-Asenjo, E. (2011) Economic evidence in private-enforcement competition law in Spain, European Competition Law Review, 32(10), str. 507–512.

Ferčič, A. (2007) Škoda kot rezultat kršitve konkurenčnega prava in pravne posledice v sferi korporacijskega in obligacijskega prava, Zbornik znanstvenih razprav Pravne fakultete Univerze v Mariboru (Maribor: Univerza v Mariboru, Pravna fakulteta), str. 63–77.

Jones, A., Sufrin, B. (2008) EC Competition Law: Text, Cases and Materials (Oxford: Oxford University Press).

Jones, A., Beard, D. (2002) Co-contractors, Damages and Article 81: The ECJ Finally Speaks, European Competition Law Review, 23(5), str. 250–256.

Oxera (2009) Quantifying antitrust damages towards non-binding guidance for courts, študija za Direktorat za konkurenco (dostopno na spletni strani: http://ec.europa.eu/competition/antitrust/actionsdamages/quantification_study.pdf).

Wils, W., (2003) Should Private Antirtust Enforcement Be Encouraged in Europe?, World Competition, 26(3), str. 473–488.

Published
2012-12-12
How to Cite
Bratina T. (2012). Ekonomski vidiki določanja odškodnin v primeru kršitev pravil konkurenčnega prava. LeXonomica, 4(1), 73-90. Retrieved from https://journals.um.si/index.php/lexonomica/article/view/1103
Section
Articles