Leibniz and Kant about perfection and notion of picturesque in Kant
Keywords:
perfection, Leibniz, Kant, picturesqueAbstract
The God, on Leibnizian view, is the most rational being and agent and his choice explains the contingent character of the world: this world is such as it is due to God’s choice and God chose it because this is the best of all possible worlds. This is the best of all possible worlds because it comprise the greatest possible degree of being (reality) and shows the harmony (unity) of greatest multiplicity (diversity). All these are characteristics of perfection. Perfection is the concept around which evolves the rationalist picture of the world.
Kant moves heaven and earth to undermine this rationalist concept in ethics and, especially, aesthetics. One thread of this effort is weaved in his deliberations and arguing about natural and artistic beauty. In this deliberations perfection gives way to the concept of purpose, which is not to be confused with former. The role of purpose in Kant’s aesthetics is not constitutive but only regulative, that is, »beautiful art must be regarded as nature, although of course one is aware of it as art«. In art of pleasure garden we do not need the concepts of the objects and its ends or purposes (as, for example, in architecture) as the condition of its arrangement but we must look on them as if arranged according to some purpose or intention. Gardens are supposed to be the domain of irregularity, follies, chaos, ruin, and whims. Gardens are here »merely to be viewed, in order to entertain the imagination in free play with ideas and to occupy the power of aesthetic judgment without a determinate end«. Looking at gardens offers us the occasion for exercising the free play of our cognitive faculties, imagination and understanding. The new war cry is freedom and from here to famous Schiller’s dictum »that beauty is freedom in appearance« is only one small step.
The point of Kantian view on pleasure gardens is not only that they are picturesque (that we look at them in terms of picture or painting) but that they are literary paintings. The concept of picturesque is thereby driven up to its extreme: nature (pleasure garden) is painting. This is one of the reasons why Kant carefully avoids the usage of the term “picturesque”: there is no need to use it.
Downloads
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2013 Društvo za analitično filozofijo in filozofijo znanosti

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.