Purpose, Aesthetic Ideas, and Morality
Keywords:
beauty, sublime, aesthetic ideas, purposivness without purpuseAbstract
Since the apprehension of pure beauty includes an appreciation of an object’s purposiveness without purpose, and not purposiveness with purpose, the appreciation of the beauty of a work of art as such poses a dilemma.
One horn of the dilemma suggests the apprehension of the object’s purposive form in absolute abstraction from the fact, that it was the product of intentional action. We would then consider the work of art as a natural object. The other horn is to conceive the artwork’s purposive form as exhibiting a purposiveness with purpose and fail to appreciate the artwork’s beauty. Kant’s solution to this problem, with respect to representational art, springs up from his appreciation of how art can represent the actual things in daily life and yet have an illusionary dimension. Let us take as an example an artist’s painting of a flower that represents the flower faithfully and accurately. Both the painting and the flower, viewed in the abstract as pure designs, could both be beautiful and perhaps the same judgment of pure beauty would be given in relation to each configuration. When we judge the flower’s beauty, taking into account that it is a natural object, then its pure beauty becomes an object of moral interest, since there is significant difference between apprehending some form whose provenance is left indeterminate, as opposed to apprehending some form that we know arose naturally and outside of the forces of human condition.
At the end of the paper I defend the thesis that duty is characterized as sublime because the experience of it is first and foremost the experience of a power of resistance against natural inclinations; and the asthetic experience of the sublime seems to bea n experience only of such a power of resistance conceived negatively and thus without any positive presentation of its origin.
Downloads
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2014 Društvo za analitično filozofijo in filozofijo znanosti

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.