Modelling Intuitions and Thought Experiments
Keywords:
thought experiment, intuitions, mental models, epistemic Platonism, nativismAbstract
The first, critical part of the paper summarizes J. R. Brown’s Platonic view on thought experiments (TEs) and raises several questions. One of them concerns the initial, particular judgments in a TE. Since they seem to precede the general insight, Brown’s Platonic intuition, and not to derive from it the question arises as to the nature of the initial particular judgment. Other question concern the explanatory status of Brown’s epistemic Platonism. The second, constructive descriptive-explanatory part argues for an alternative, i.e. the view of TE as reasoning in or with a help of mental models, which can accommodate all the relevant data within a non-aprioristic framework (or, at worst, within a minimally “aprioristic”, nativist one). The last part turns to issues of justification and argues that the mental model proposal can account for justification of intuitional judgments and can also support the view of properly functioning intuition as an epistemic virtue, all within a more naturalist framework than the one endorsed by Brown.
Downloads
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2007 Društvo za analitično filozofijo in filozofijo znanosti

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.