Philosophy between Science and Humanities
Keywords:
analytic philosophy, naturalism, explanationism, eliminativism, accomodationismAbstract
In this paper I shall talk mainly about the future of analytic philosophy. Analytic philosophy has at least since logical positivism been uncomfortably balancing between two cultures, the scientific and the humanistic one. Two out of three Founding fathers of analytic philosophy, Frege and Russell, saw it as clearly aligned with the scientific culture. However, philosophy as a whole was associated with arts and humanities throughout the nineteenth century, and it has kept the liaisons until the present time. Some disciplines, like aesthetics, ethics, political philosophy and philosophy of history, clearly addressed the issues central to humanities, while others, like philosophy of mind and of language have at times shared the ground with humanistic culture. Analytic tradition recaptured some of the ground in last half century.
So the general idea is the following. Use the bridgeheads that have already been created! Grab the best of both cultures, scientific and humanistic ones! Avoid giving up on either of the two! Further, I am arguing that what is of lasting importance in naturalism is a stress on explanation, complementing the more normative interest. In the case of naturalism, this lasting importance has been obscured by the loud noise of eliminativist naturalism. My own sympathies are, on the contrary, with accommodationist rather than eliminativist approach: we have to explain the interesting phenomena rather than explain them away. And we have to show how they are possible either within a broadly natural order, or at least in relation to it. My own accommodationist favorite in epistemology is a more explanation-focused variant of Sosa-style virtue account.
Downloads
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2005 Društvo za analitično filozofijo in filozofijo znanosti

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.