Critical Considerations about Rawls’s The Law of Peoples

Authors

  • Milan Franc Faculty of Arts, University of Maribor

Keywords:

cosmopolitanism, theory of justice, principles of (re)distribution, state of nature, human rights, globalisation

Abstract

In my article I want to concentrate on several important lines of criticism regarding Rawls’ Law of Peoples. The major topics that I am dealing with are divided into what I hope to be conclusive subchapters.

The first subchapter addresses the troublesome use of Rawls’ basic categories. Together with several other critical philosophers I am trying to argue that Rawls fails to make a clear distinction between some of his crucial concepts, which makes his theory quite unintelligible.

The following two subchapters emphasise the need for redefinition of Rawls’ conceptions of the ’state(s) of nature’, thereby suggesting that one common global state of nature could provide a better foundation for his model of global, or international justice.

Next, I turn to somewhat harsh Rawls’ presumption according to which only burdened societies can fully justify the need for help, and therefore any demand for possible redistribution would be nullified. Naturally, I want to argue that’s hardly true because of the significant change in today’s economic environment.

Further, Rawls seems to have an acute problem with the content and range of human rights. Consequently, he suggest two different types of their application and validity, for which I think that they could hardly be estimated as consistent with the concept of democratic cosmopolitanism.

Finally, I find myself inclined to the solution, also proposed by a few other political philosophers who envisage a cosmopolitan state of nature with some form of generalised Rawlsian principles of justice. I thus conclude with a general evaluation of Rawls’ international, or global justice theory.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Published

31.08.2012

Issue

Section

Articles

How to Cite

Franc, M. (2012). Critical Considerations about Rawls’s The Law of Peoples. Analiza: časopis Za Kritično Misel, 16(1-2), 35–62. https://journals.um.si/index.php/analiza/article/view/7057