The Riddle of Experience: The Role of First- and Second-Person Methods in Cognitive Science

Authors

  • Toma Strle Faculty of Education, University of Ljubljana

Keywords:

choice blindness, conscious deliberation, decision making, experience, first- and second-person methods, neurophenomenology, phenomenological reduction

Abstract

In the paper I will defend the view that in cognitive science it is essential to use systematic first- and second-person methods for better understanding of the human mind. Neurophenomenological programme put forward by Varela (2013 [1996]) as a solution to the hard problem of consciousness (Chalmers: 2013 [1995]) does not solve the hard problem on the ontological level (question of ontological reduction of consciousness), but nonetheless represents a good methodological proposal of systematic inquiry into conscious experience. On the other hand, the criterion of phenomenological reduction as a necessary condition for systematic investigation of experience is too strong. Regardless of that and some other problems first- and second-person methods face, it is becoming clear that investigating experience from first- and second-person perspectives is becoming more and more necessary in cognitive science. Giving some examples from the broader area od decision making I try to show that this is indeed the case – it especially holds for cases where the differentiation between conscious and unconscious is of prime importance (e.g. in answering the question whether conscious deliberation leads to better or worse choices than unconscious processes). Furthermore, gathering experiential data is essential for interpreting experimental results gained purely by quantitative methods – especially when we are implicitly or explicitly referring to experiential states in our interpretations.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Published

30.11.2013

Issue

Section

Articles

How to Cite

Strle, T. (2013). The Riddle of Experience: The Role of First- and Second-Person Methods in Cognitive Science. Analiza: časopis Za Kritično Misel, 17(1-2), 41–60. https://journals.um.si/index.php/analiza/article/view/7039