And What Is This Thing Called ‘Metaphysics’?
Keywords:
contemporary metaphysics, Aristotle, ontology, nature, criticism of metaphysicsAbstract
The article provides a historical introduction into modern (analytic) metaphysics as the core philosophical discipline. Aristotelian starting points (‘first philosophy’, ‘the study of being qua being’, ‘theology‘) are labeled as Metaphysics 1.0 (supplemented and revised in the Middle Ages as versions 1.1., 1.2., etc.). A new conception, Metaphysics 2.0, emerges in the 17th century with the rise of modem science. Traditional philosophical problems of physics and other problems, not belonging to other branches of philosophy (cosmology, mind-body, causation, personal identity, freedom of will, ...) were now allocated to metaphysics. A complex relation between metaphysics and ontology is briefly analyzed. In accordance with some modem approaches I understand ontology as the part of the metaphysics whose subject matter are the most general questions of being. A survey of modem metaphysics reveals a certain core (philosophical – conceptual investigation of the most general questions about the nature of reality), but boundaries are not clear. The most abstract problems and questions of being and nature are perhaps no longer o subject matter of a special discipline; rather they form the most general and abstract part of any branch of theoretical knowledge (Metaphysics 3.0). Metaphysics as synonymous with philosophy has been »buried« several times. I critically examine and (briefly) refute the following criticisms: (i) metaphysics is not aware of its preconditions and presuppositions; (ii) there is no objective truth to be revealed by metaphysical investigations; (iii) metaphysical problems are to be solved by the analysis of language; (iv) metaphysical problems are to be solved by science, there is no special philosophical approach.
Downloads
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2012 Društvo za analitično filozofijo in filozofijo znanosti

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.