Politics from Armchair: From Plato to Rawls

Authors

  • Nenad Miščević Faculty of Arts, University of Maribor, and Central European University

Keywords:

thought experiment, thought experiment in political philosophy, Plato, Rousseau, Rawls

Abstract

Choosing the examples from three fundamental works of political philosophy, Plato’s The Republic, Rousseau’s The social contract, and Rawls’s A theory of justice, we emphasized the importance of extensive thought experiments in political philosophy. We consider four wished for attributes of such experiments, especially attributes that characterize the suggested and imagined scenarios: the importance of elements and details, realisticality and stability of scenario. For that, we combined two descriptions: the description, borrowed from science, which talks about the control of variables, and the description, borrowed from semantics of modality, which talks about contra-factual judgments and their truth-values. The first description suggests the choice of significant variables and reasonable attribution of values to these variables, the second advances the realisticality and acceptability of imagined model.

We briefly advocate political TE against inferential view according to which they are only popular disguised conclusions. We argue on the ground of some starting points that point to the significance of a particular contrary to the universal principles and comprehensions. First, on the underlying fact that principles and their direct application require moral testing and one of the main sources of judging are precisely moral intuitions that arise from TE. Second, on the underlying fact that these principles require just same kind of test settled with equal means. Alternatively, if we pass over to particular norms and principles then transition itself as the norms and principles need additional testing.

We conclude that in practical philosophy it will not do without TE. True, they are replete with problems and snares but are the best what we have. They need to be supplemented by empirical-theoretical values but cannot be compensated by them. We did not advocate here more positive view, namely that large ME codetermine or even determine the whole history of political philosophy but the three key books to which we appeal to considerably suggest that also this view might be acceptable.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Published

31.12.2012

Issue

Section

Articles

How to Cite

Miščević, N. (2012). Politics from Armchair: From Plato to Rawls. Analiza: časopis Za Kritično Misel, 16(4), 57–73. https://journals.um.si/index.php/analiza/article/view/7027