Introduction to Deontic Logic

Authors

  • Danilo Šuster Faculty of Arts, Maribor

Keywords:

deontic logic, modal logic, system SDL, paradoxes of deontic logic

Abstract

A short introduction to deontic logic is presented. Traditional philosophical approaches to practical and ethical reasoning are sketched (Aristotle – practical syllogism; Hume and Hume’s law – ’ought’ can not be derived from ’is’). Deontic logic proper is based on an analogy between deontic and alethic modality as displayed in the modal square of oppositions. Deontic logic is not extensional, so the starting point for deontic logic (also called logic of norms, logic of obligations, logic of normative systems, logic of imperatives) is a treatment of obligation as a special case of necessity. Modal logics are nowadays well investigated intensional systems. Deontic logic is presented in the form of an axiomatic system. Standard system of deontic logic (SDL) is analysed, every thesis and rule is explained in detail and derivations of typical consequences are given. At the end challenges to standard deontic logics in the form of dilemmas and paradoxes are presented (Jørgensen’s dilemma – how can there be a logic of normative sentences?); free choice permission paradox (or Ross’ paradox); Good Samaritan and contrary-to-duty paradox and the problem of moral dilemmas. Most plausible solutions point to expressive inadequacies of SDL and problems of treating deontic logic just as a special case of modal logic.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Published

30.11.2008

Issue

Section

Articles

How to Cite

Šuster, D. (2008). Introduction to Deontic Logic. Analiza: časopis Za Kritično Misel, 12(3), 5–28. https://journals.um.si/index.php/analiza/article/view/6829