Competent Voices: A Theory of Intuitions
Abstract
The paper honors Dunja Jutronić’s work by discussing her view of linguistic intuitions and intuitions in general. The “ordinarist” views (D. Jutronić, M. Devitt, and T. Williamson) deny that intuitions are special in any regard, and insist on holistic justification for them, of a unitary, either aposteriori or neutral variety. The paper proposes the sketch of an alternative, a pluralistic intuitionism-competentialism, according to which intuition is special, since intuitions are deliverances of competence, linguistic, spatial-geometrical, metaphysical, moral, and so on, the stance dubbed here “the Moderate Voice-of-Competence view”. It agrees with the ordinarists that intuitions are extroverted, turned to their referential domain, in contrast to the views of conceptualists. It also agrees about explanationism, and about the importance of scenarios and simulation in generating intuitions in contrast to pure logical reasoning. It disagrees with them in defending a pluralistic aposteriorism: intuitions are justified a priori in a prima facie and sometimes superficial way at the level of immediate acceptance, but mainly a posteriori on the higher, reflective level, needed for full-scale knowledge. Finally, the metaphysical pluralism of the proposed view comes to fore in distinguishing intuition-kinds, like moral and linguistic ones whose object is (taken here to be) response-dependent, from those whose object is completely mind-independent.
Downloads
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2010 Društvo za analitično filozofijo in filozofijo znanosti

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.