Ule’s Criticism of Horgan’s Account of Truth as Mediated Correspondence
Keywords:
truth, direct and mediated correspondence, correct assertibility/affirmability, contextually operative semantic standards, illusion, vagueness, epistemic standardsAbstract
In his book “The Attainability of Truth” Andrej Ule presents several theories, including the conception of truth as indirect or mediated correspondence that was initially developed by Terry Horgan. Truth as mediated correspondence and the underlying account of limited metaphysical realism are briefly discussed. Mediated correspondence, for a given thought/sentence, is semantic correctness under contextually operative semantic standards. Such conceptual mediation involves two factors: first there are contextually operative standards for semantic correctness, whereas on the other hond there is the actual distribution of genuine properties by genuine objects in the world. Considering this, we are able to explain truth of numerous sentences and statements that we use in our every-day life and also in scientific language, with the following characteristics: (i) we take them to be unproblematically true; (ii) these sentences mention and quantify over entities that should not be countenanced within or compose the right minimal naturalistic ontology; (iii) there is no obvious way to paraphrase these statements into ones that avoid commitment to problematic entities; (iv) there is no plausible way to identify the proble- matic entities with ontologically unproblematic ones. Ule’s arguments against mediated correspondence, such as argument from illusion and argument from vagueness are discussed. Some weak points of his criticism are revealed. last part of the paper briefly deals with the relationship between contextual variation of semantic standards and epistemic standards.
Downloads
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2005 Društvo za analitično filozofijo in filozofijo znanosti

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.