Reproductive Rights, Child’s Interests, and Slovene Law on the Medical Treatment of Infertility

Authors

  • Friderik Klampfer Faculty of Education, University of Maribor

Keywords:

Slovene Law on the medical treatment of infertility, justice, (unjust or wrongful) discrimination, reproductive rights, child’s interests

Abstract

The paper deals with some perplexing moral dilemmas concerning the recent initiative of the Slovene government to introduce substantial changes into the existing law on the biomedical treatment of infertility. The author discusses and rejects as unconvincing the main arguments put forward by the opponents of the most controversial change: the suggestion to include among those entitled to the use of the methods of assisted procreation women without partners who hove not been (conclusively) proved infertile in the course of regular heterosexual intercourse: (i) that the existing legal arrangement, despite denying the legal right to such assistance to single women, violates neither the principle of justice nor the constitutional norm of equality before the law, hence there can be no compelling moral or legal reasons for such a change; (ii) that the recommended arrangement would make it possible for single women to exercise their reproductive rights, but only at the expense of the interests of the future (thereby conceived) child; (iii) that, given the plausibility of the claim that the existent law’s denial of the right to assisted procreation for single women makes this low unjust and unconstitutional, the new arrangement would fare no better, for it would still wrongly discriminate against single men; (iv) that by supplementing exclusively medical reasons for such a treatment with non-medical ones, the recommended legal arrangement would generously make room for abuses; (v) that because the use of the methods of assisted procreation would constitute in the case of (probably fertile) single female patients a non-standard, extraordinary medical treatment, the costs should be borne by the patients themselves; and (vi) that the suggested change runs counter to the very concept of the existing law and the basic intention of the legislator which was to legalize the use of assisted procreation as a method of infertility treatment. In addition to the rebuttal of the above arguments, the author shows why the suggested changes would make the existent law less arbitrarily restrictive and thus morally preferred to the one in force at present.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Published

30.06.2001

Issue

Section

Articles

How to Cite

Klampfer, F. (2001). Reproductive Rights, Child’s Interests, and Slovene Law on the Medical Treatment of Infertility. Analiza: časopis Za Kritično Misel, 5(1-2), 3–26. https://journals.um.si/index.php/analiza/article/view/6877