Intention and Artwork

Authors

  • Božidar Kante Faculty of Arts, University of Maribor

Keywords:

intentional fallacy, absolute intentionalism, moderate intentionalism, hypothetical intentionalism, categorical intentions, semantic intentions, J. Levinson

Abstract

The beginning of the paper deals with the so called “intentional fallacy” and then considers five reasons why W. K. Wimsatt Junior and M. Beardsely disagree with intentional account of an artwork. After that we turn to the presentation and critical account of various intentional positions. In this terms we start with the analysis of seminal Walton’s work “Categories of Art” in which he uses intentions for undermining the empiricism in aesthetics. Contrary to empiricism in aesthetics Walton argues that some facts about the origin of an artwork have in criticism the essential role. The central part of paper focuses on the hypothetical intentionalism and its drawbacks. Hypothetical intentionalism claims that the meaning of an artworks is determined by inferences which are made by suitably positioned public about intentions of supposed (hypothetical author) while these inferences are based on the understanding of language conventions and artistic practices of certain periods as well as on the publicly accessible knowledge about certain artwork. The last part of the paper is devoted to the objections raised against J. Levinson’s variant of hypothetical intentionalism. First, Levinson does not offer any systematic way how to make demarcation between categorical and semantic intentions. Second, why is it that semantic intentions cannot play the constitutive role – they are prejudged to play only regulative role. And further, Levinson’s interpretation of Kafka’s work Ein Landartz in which is he absolutely neglectful about the discovery of real Kafka’s intentions is controversial not only in epistemic but also in ethical sense. If the goal of interpretation is truth or some kind of approximation of truth, then the interpretation which neglects explicit authorial intentions violates the truth and factual state of affairs.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Published

31.05.2007

Issue

Section

Articles

How to Cite

Kante, B. (2007). Intention and Artwork. Analiza: časopis Za Kritično Misel, 11(1-2), 83–103. https://journals.um.si/index.php/analiza/article/view/6798