Introduction to the Discussion about Pornography

Authors

  • Božidar Kante Faculty of Education, University of Maribor

Keywords:

sexual moral, pornography, human rights, freedom of expression, sexual discrimination

Abstract

The article goes back to the history of discussion about pornography and shows how the emphasis and the center of gravity of discussion have shifted. It is also a critical survey of the views advocated by liberal philosophers and theoreticians, conservatives and feminists.

The controversy about pornography started in terms of the question about genuine borders of sexual freedom. Such an attitude was due to the fact of people’s paying attention to only one feature of pornography, namely its sexual content. If pornography was anyhow problematic at all it was thought to represent a problem because the issue of pornography was the issue about genuine borders of sexual moral. Later, the discussion has shifted on the domain of human rights. To the forefront of study came the relationship between the freedom of expression and the pornography. Any suggestion in favor of the restriction or prohibition of some form or all forms of pornography immediately encounters the reaction of the antipole who appeals to the right of free speech. People who wish the pornography to be restricted or prohibited have to show the problematic side of pornography and advocates of the right of free speech have to tell why the freedom of expression is important and to what degree.

Finally, if the right to free speech is a right to genuine communication in which the principle of reciprocity holds then the view of liberals about what threats the freedom of expression is unsound and too narrow. So it seems that the feminist argument against liberals, that is, argument that pornography establishes the conflict between pornographers’ freedom of speech and feminist freedom of speech, is in better position to be successful and it appears more obligatory. At the same time, the introduction of the theory of speech acts in the discussion enables pornography to be considered as a form of discrimination, on a par with sexual harassment and race discrimination. All these set the terms for a new round of philosophical and legal discussion. These facts are crucial in taking our position that restriction of some form of pornography is likely justified.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Published

30.06.2003

Issue

Section

Articles

How to Cite

Kante, B. (2003). Introduction to the Discussion about Pornography. Analiza: časopis Za Kritično Misel, 7(1-2), 37–64. https://journals.um.si/index.php/analiza/article/view/6779