Patriotism: A Deflationary View
Keywords:
communitarianism, liberalism, partialism, patriotism, universalismAbstract
The author discusses the moral standing of patriotism as an issue in the debates between universalists and partialists in ethics and between liberals and communitarians in political philosophy. He looks into and tries to refute six arguments for the claim that patriotism is a moral duty: from ordinary belief, gratitude, reciprocity, utility, moral growth and sustenance, and identity. He also rejects the view that patriotism is optional, but morally valuable if adopted. The conclusion is that, morally speaking, there is nothing to be said for patriotism: it is, at best, a morally permissible type of partiality.