Respect for Human Dignity, Undignified Life, and Dignified Death
Keywords:
euthanasia, autonomy, human dignity, the principle of respect for person’s dignity, undignified life, dignity-preserving deathAbstract
The paper deals with the moral status of active voluntary euthanasia: can a terminally-ill patient’s request to be allowed or even helped to die, ever be morally legitimate, and if yes, under what conditions? Furthermore, can it ever be morally justified for a doctor or some other authorized person to meet such a demand, and if yes, under what circumstances? I do not intend to offer conclusive proof to the effect that no moral concern regarding such actions is valid. I set out to prove instead that one of the more philosophically interesting objections against the practice of active voluntary euthanasia, namely that the patient and the collaborating physician, in intending to bring about the patient’s death, offend his human dignity, is misplaced. In the course of doing that, I discuss at length and finally reject an interesting idea of the contemporary American philosopher David J. Velleman. According to Velleman, it may be permissible to deliberately take the life of a person only when that person has irremediably lost her capacity for autonomous and rational choice, in which her dignity (i.e. her unconditional, intrinsic, final, incomensurable and incomparable value) resides. In which case, however, she is no longer capable of making a competent and thus a morally and legally binding decision to end her life. Against this I argue, by way of an example, that due to the disease the person’s dignity can be irremediably compromised, even though her capacity for autonomous and rational choice (or decision-making) is left more or less intact. In such circumstances, killing a terminally-ill patient at her request and for her own benefit will not constitute an objectionable disregard of the valid moral demand to always show, in our attitudes and action, respect for the dignity of every person affected by them.
Downloads
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2002 Društvo za analitično filozofijo in filozofijo znanosti

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.