Imagined Communities and Their Moral Standing: The Example of Nation
Keywords:
nationalism, national myth, constructed identities, obligationAbstract
If a belonging is illusory then it cannot bestow obligations upon anyone. Belonging to an “imagined” community depends upon beliefs in a false, “covertly constructed” picture of one’s society. To the extent to which nation is such a covertly constructed community, the alleged obligations towards it are illusory and null. It is argued here that mistaken beliefs about moral obligation leads to morally questionable practice, imposing the wrong order of priorites in general, and the wrong choice of the scope of one’s obligation. Further, being born and socialized into an (other-) constructed identity with little chance of exit is conducive neither to dignity nor to autonomy. Finally, the cultural and political importance of covert construction can and often does produce dangerous spillover, given the nasty character of founding national myths. The imagined character of national community thus has serious moral consequences that work against pro-nationalist views. This conclusion stands in marked contrast to assumptions in recent “liberal national” literature (Tamir, Miller, MacCormick) who find “imagined” belonging not only harmless, but morally appealing and for whom, as Tamir puts it “living within a community where members share an imagined sense of togetherness engenders mutual responsibilities”.
Downloads
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2001 Društvo za analitično filozofijo in filozofijo znanosti

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.