Medical Error – Should it be a Criminal Offence?

Miha Šepec

Abstract


Medicine is a risky profession where medical professionals have a duty to do anything in their power to help their patients. However, what if a doctor makes a grievous mistake that leads to the death but could have been avoided? Are moral responsibility and apology to patients’ family enough? Should we impose sanctions (civil or criminal) on the doctor who negligently caused the patients’ death? To answer this questions, we present arguments against criminalisation of medical error, where the strongest arguments are uncertainty of medical standards, counterproductive criminalisation seen in defensive medicine, using criminal law as the last resort, and the argument of doctor’s immunity. On the other hand, arguments for criminalisation are obvious negligent treatment with serious consequences, general prevention of future negligent conduct, sanitation of a medical system gone wrong, and the argument of privileged criminal offence. Our conclusion is that criminal law repression of medical malpractice or medical error is justified, however only in the most obvious cases of undisputed negligence or carelessness of a doctor, where his inappropriate conduct has led to a serious deterioration of health of a patient, which could have easily been avoided, if a doctor respected the practice and rules of medical science and profession.


Keywords


Medical error, criminal law, criminal offence, medical malpractice, doctor, medical professional, negligent treatment.

Full Text:

PDF

References


Ashworth, A. & Holder, J. (2013) Principles of Criminal Law, 7th ed. (Oxford: Oxford University Press).

Bavcon, L., Šelih, A., Korošec, D., Ambrož, M. & Filipčič. K. (2014) Kazensko pravo, splošni del (Ljubljana: Uradni list Republike Slovenije).

Brenner, L., Brenner, A., Awerbuch, E. & Horwits, D. (2012) Beyond the Standard of Care: A New Model to Judge Medical Negligence, Clinical Orthopaedics and Related research, 470(5), pp. 1357-1364, doi: 10.1007/s11999-012-2280-0.

Criminal Code of the Republic of Slovenia (KZ-1) adopted in 2008, last amended in 2017, Slovenian Parliament.

Dežman, Z. (2010) Zakon o pacientovih pravicah in njegov kazensko pravni vidik, In: Rijavec, V., Reberšek Gorišek, J., Flis, V., Planinšec, V. & Kraljič, S. (eds.) Medicina in pravo, sodobne dileme II (Maribor: Faculty of Law of University of Maribor), pp. 375-388.

Dworkin, R. (1988) Law’s Empire (Cambridge: Harvard University Press).

Flis, V. (1994) Medicinska napaka, In: Flis, V. & Planinšec, V. (eds.) Medicina in pravo II, Odgovornost zdravnika, Medicinska napaka (Maribor: Slovensko zdravniško društvo v Mariboru in Pravniško društvo v Mariboru), pp. 47-67.

Flis, V. (2016) No Fault Compensation for Medical Injuries, Medicine, Law & Society, 9(2), pp. 73-84, doi: 10.18690/24637955.9.2.73-84(2016)

Grunsven, P. (1997) Medical Malpractice or Criminal Mistake – An Analysis of Past and Current Criminal Prosecutions for Clinical Mistakes and Fatal Errors, DePaul Journal of Health Care Law, 2(1), pp. 1-54.

Halmich, M. (2016) Strafrechtsnovelle bringt Änderungenim Medizinstrafrecht, available at: https://www.halmich.at/strafrechtsnovelle-bringt-aenderungen-immedizinstrafrecht/ (December 5, 2017).

Heller Allan, T. (2017) An Overview of Medical Malpractice Law in the United States Including Legislative and the Health Care Industry’s Responses to Increased Claims, Medicine, Law & Society, 10(2), pp. 139-163, doi: 10.18690/2463-7955.10.2.139- 163.2017.

Helmer, O. & Rescher, N. (1959) On the Epistemology of Inexact Sciences, Management Science, 6(1), pp. 25-52, doi: 10.1287/mnsc.6.1.25.

Jere Jakulin, V. (2017) Systems Methodology for Strategic Decision-making in Complex Healthcare Systems, Medicine, Law & Society, 10(2), pp. 121-138, doi: 10.18690/2463-7955.10.2.121-138.2017.

Jescheck, H. H. & Weigend, T. (1996) Lehrbuch des Strafrechts, Allgemeiner Teil (Berlin: Duncker & Humblot).

Kennerly, M. (2017) Medicine Is Not An Exact Science (Countering A Defensive Medicine Myth), available at: https://www.litigationandtrial.com/2013/12/articles/attorney/exact-sciencedefensive-medicine-myth/ (December 7, 2017)

King, L. S. (1952) Is Medicine an exact science? Philosophy of Science, 19, pp. 131-140, doi: 10.1086/287185.

Kohn, L., Corrigan, J. & Donaldson, M. (2000) To Err Is Human: Building a Safer Health System (Washington: National Academies Press).

Korošec, D. (2016) Medicinsko kazensko pravo, 2nd ed. (Ljubljana: GV Založba).

Korošec, D. (2016) Criminal Law Dillemas in Withholding and Withdrawal of Intensive Care, Medicine, Law & Society, 9(1), pp. 21-39, doi: 10.18690/24637955.9.1.21- 39(2016).

Leflar, R. & Iwata, F. (2005) Medical Error as Reportable Event, as Tort, as Crime: A Transpacific Comparison, Widener Law Review, 12, pp. 189-225.

Lefler, R. (2009) The Regulation of Medical Malpractice in Japan, Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research, 467(2), pp. 443-449, doi: 10.1007/s11999-008-0602-z.

Matz, S. (1989) Der ärtzliche Kunstfehler und sein Beweis, In: Kaufman, A. (ed.) Moderne Medizin und Strafrecht (Heidelberg: CF Müller Juristischer Verlag).

Merry, A. (2009) How does the law recognize and deal with medical errors? Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, 102(7), pp. 265-271, doi: 10.1258/jrsm.2009.09k029.

Miller, R., Sampson, N. & Flynn, J. (2012) The prevalence of defensive orthopaedic imaging: a prospective practice audit in Pennsylvania, Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery, 94(3), doi: 10.2106/JBJS.K.00646.

Oyebode, F. (2013) Clinical Errors and Medical Negligence, Medical Principles and Practice, 22(4), pp. 323-333, doi: 10.1159/000346296.

Pandit, M. & Pandit, S. (2009) Medical negligence: Criminal prosecution of medical professionals, importance of medical evidence: Some guidelines for medical practitioners, Indian Journal of Urology, 25(3), pp. 329-383, doi: 10.4103/0970- 1591.56207.

Pandit, M. & Pandit, S. (2009) Medical negligence: Coverage of the profession, duties, ethics, case law, and enlightened defence – A legal perspective, Indian Journal of Urology, 25(3), pp. 372-378, doi: 10.4103/0970-1591.56206.

Prosser, W. (1978) Law of Torts, 4th ed. (Minnesota: West Publishing Company)

Roxin, C. (2003) Strafrecht, Allgemeiner Teil II, Besondere Erscheinungsformen der Straftat (München: Beck).

Ormerod, D. (2005) Smith & Hogan Criminal Law, 11th ed. (New York: Oxford University Press).

Sonny Bal, B. (2009) An Introduction to Medical Malpractice in the United States, Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research, 467(2), pp. 339-347, doi: 10.1007/s11999- 008-0636-2.

Turković, M. (2012) Nesavjesno liječenje, Ius Info, available at: http://www.iusinfo.com.hr/DailyContent/Topical.aspx?id=13137 (December 18, 2017)

Zwitter, M. (2012) Položaj zdravnika v sodobni družbi, In: Reberšek Gorišek, J. & Ivanc, T. (ed.) Medicina in pravo, Odsev medicine in prava v sodobni družbi (Maribor: Faculty of Law of University of Maribor), pp. 63-69.


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.